Saturday, September 3, 2011

vaccine controversy


As we have noted vaccines play an important role in the history of immunology. It is a fact that they have saved millions of lives. In many ways we take them for granted. Yet vaccines like any medical treatments are not without risks. And it appears that little has changed since Jenner's time regarding the view of some vaccines by the general public. Perhaps the most controversial is the MMR vaccine and its suspected relationship to autism. Several reports have come out in the last year saying that there is no connection yet many believe that there is a connection.
For this blog investigate some of the controversy known about various vaccines and answer the following questions:

1 What are the risks associated with vaccines?
2 What have been some of the documented side-effects?
3 What is your personal view of vaccine safety?
4 Will you allow your children to be vaccinated?

15 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. One of the risks associated with vaccines is that the patient, especially if a child, will develop some type of disorder. Though the autism disorder has not been directly linked to vaccination, there is evidence for and against this supposition. Other risks associated with vaccination include developing an allergic reaction, becoming semi or very sick, and even dying. Documented side-effects of vaccination include allergic reactions, fevers, pain, inflammation, headaches, general weakness, and in severe cases, deafness, long-term seizures, and permanent brain damage (http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/side-effects.htm). Death is by far the most drastic "side-effect" of vaccination and can be the result of a fatal sensitivity to the antigen (anaphylaxis).
    My personal view of vaccine safety is positive. I feel that the evidence supporting their safety and over-all effectiveness out-rules any minor side-effects that have been documented. Death by vaccination is very rare and a direct link between disorders such as autism and vaccines has not been established. Therefore, I will allow my children to be vaccinated and will continue to be vaccinated myself if a further need should arise. If a direct and damaging link between vaccines and autism arises, I will look into the vaccine(es) linked to the disorder and will most likely not vaccinate my children with them. However, the number of children with autism disorder will have to be high for me to refuse to use the vaccine.

    ReplyDelete
  3. An interesting idea is the suggested link between human DNA in vaccines and autism. It appears that around when autism began spiking (1995), chicken pox vaccine administered was grown in human fetal tissue. This introduction of foreign DNA might alter the host DNA and cause brain cells to be under constant attack. This would result in continual inflammation and ever-present autism symptoms.
    http://informahealthcare.com/eprint/RT45Mr7pFWDtSU75h3QV/full?tokenKey=&&

    ReplyDelete
  4. The Risks and Side-effects:

    "Mild Problems

    * Fever (about 1 child out of 5).
    * Mild rash (about 1 child out of 20).
    * Swelling of glands in the cheeks or neck (rare).

    If these problems happen, it is usually within 5-12 days after the fi rst dose. They happen less often after the second dose.

    Moderate Problems

    * Seizure caused by fever (about 1 child in 1,250 who get MMRV), usually 5-12 days after the first dose. They happen less often when MMR and varicella vaccines are given at the same visit as separate shots (about 1 child in 2,500 who get these two vaccines), and rarely after a 2nd dose of MMRV.
    * Temporary low platelet count, which can cause a bleeding disorder (about 1 child out of 40,000).

    Severe Problems (Very Rare)
    Several severe problems have been reported following MMR vaccine, and might also happen after MMRV. These include severe allergic reactions (fewer than 4 per million), and problems such as:

    * Deafness.
    * Long-term seizures, coma, lowered consciousness.
    * Permanent brain damage.

    Because these problems occur so rarely, we can’t be sure whether they are caused by the vaccine or not."

    -Center for Disease Control


    Vaccine Safety:

    The vaccine does have potential side effects, like all medical treatments. However, it is statistically proven that it is significantly more beneficial than detrimental to public health. Hence, it is a viable medical treatment. Moreover, the federal government has an injury compensation program for the few who experience serious side-effects.

    Most of the claims that vaccines are contributing to autism were directed at the preservative thimerosal, a mercury-containing compound, which coincidentally wasn't in any vaccines for years before we began to see the current spike in autism-spectrum disorders.

    It would help to touch on the current data on autism-spectrum disorders, the cause of which isn't well understood, but is being rigorously investigated. The most popular current hypothesis is, in a nutshell, that when autism phenotypes rise when the collection of autism-linked mutations in the genotype reach a certain threshold. The greater number of mutations above the threshold confers a more severe autistic phenotype. Research is still being conducted to investigate this hypothesis.

    With the current data, I will allow my children to be vaccinated. Should there be objective data supporting vaccine components induce mutation, then I may reconsider my stance.

    The main reason is that if it is indeed causing mutations, and the current hypothesis eventually rings true, then it is the accumulation of mutations in genomes through generations that are contributing to this spike in autism. Therefore the vaccine would be indirectly linked to the development of autism.

    Regardless, I find the idea that autism is generated in an otherwise healthy individual due to outside stimulus to be rather far-fetched. Damage to the genome, yes, quite possible...and would have implications for future generations (or even cancer). Damage in born, functioning humans leading to the development of SEVERE autism...I find unlikely.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Christian and Emma have clearly shown the side-effects and potential consequences of vaccinations. I will move along to questions 3 and 4.
    3. I think that vaccinations are worth the potential consequences. The probability for serious side-effects is small when compared with the probability for the diseases that they could prevent. A physician entering practice today may never see a case of meningitis due to Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib). Before the introduction of effective vaccines, in 1988, approximately one in 200 children, under the age of five, developed invasive Hib disease. Hib was the leading cause of bacterial meningitis in children under age five-- accounting for about 60 percent of all cases. From 15 to 30 percent of affected children became hearing impaired and about 420 children died every year despite antibiotic therapy. In addition, Hib vaccine has prevented the leading cause of acquired mental retardation in the U.S. By 1998, vaccination of pre-school children reduced the number of Hib cases by more than 99 percent.In the 1960s, many people witnessed first-hand, the terrible effects of rubella, commonly known as German measles. During an epidemic between 1964 and 1965, about 20,000 infants were born with deafness, blindness, heart disease, mental retardation, and other birth defects because the rubella virus infected their pregnant mothers. Today, thanks to nearly universal use of an effective vaccine, the rubella virus poses virtually no threat to the children of expectant mothers.
    I would defiantly let my children be vaccinated. Its potential consequences out way the possible side-effects.

    ReplyDelete
  6. One of the most important things to consider, that are unfortunately neglected in this topic is the matter of population vaccination. Vaccines are not intended to be directed at the individual only, but the population as a whole.

    A vaccine is not intended to simply prevent people from getting sick, but it is also intended to prevent people from becoming vectors of the illness and spreading it. The severity of a widespread disease - epidemic or pandemic - is determined by a pathogen's mode and magnitude of infectiousness.

    We mustn't only consider the propensity of vaccines to prevent individual infections and deaths, but also to prevent the spread of disease. You do not have to be ill or even show symptoms to be able to transmit infections. However, vaccinated persons are significantly less likely to transmit infections to others. This cripples the pathogen's ability to spread and multiply, which typically results in mutations over generations, making them more difficult to combat.

    This is especially important among demographics which have high interactions with each other, e.g. school children. Schools have massive potential for becoming vector farms of local illness. Children spread disease amongst themselves, then bring the disease home and spread it to families, the parents of which then spread it among their associates at work. It is easy to see how vaccinating children is of critical importance to the stability of local health.

    ReplyDelete
  7. 1 What are the risks associated with vaccines?
    the risks. problems with the patient risk is that they get some of the side effects. and/or there is long term problems of the body rejecting te vaccines antibodies.

    2 What have been some of the documented side-effects? the side effect are as follows according to the vaccine
    DTaP = Vaccine Absorbed. Autism, fever, anorexia, vomiting, pneumonia, meningitis, sepsis, pertussis, convulsions, febrile, grand mal, afebrile and partial seizures, encephalopathy, brachial neuritis, Guillain-Barré syndrome, In the worst case Sudden Infant Death syndrome. The worst case usually is quite rare.

    DTaP/HepB/IPV = Seizures, diabetes mellitus, asthma, Sudden Infant Death Syndrome, upper respiratory tract infection, abnormal liver function tests, anorexia, jaundice, shock, encephalopathy, Stevens-Johnson syndrome, brachial neuritis.

    Flu Vaccine Influenza Virus Vaccine = Significant respiratory and gastrointestinal symptoms, seizure, allergic asthma , decreased appetite, increased mitochondrial encephalomyopathy, partial facial paralysis, Guillain-Barré syndrome, Bell's palsy, Stevens-Johnson syndrome, herpes zoster [shingles].

    Hep B Vaccine Hepatitis B Vaccine = Influenza, febrile seizure, anorexia, upper respiratory tract illnesses, herpes zoster, encephalitis, palpitations, arthritis, systemic lupus erthematosus (SLE), conjunctivitis, abnormal liver function tests, Guillain-Barré syndrome, Bell's palsy, multiple sclerosis, anaphylaxis, seizures.
    these facts are cited from "Vaccine Ingredients & Side Effects » Generation Rescue | Jenny McCarthy's Autism Organization." Generation Rescue I Jenny McCarthy's Autism Organization » Generation Rescue | Jenny McCarthy's Autism Organization. Web. 08 Sept. 2011. .

    3 What is your personal view of vaccine safety?
    I think that that some vaccine are very beneficial to the person taking them because it allows them to be immune to some diseases that could make them seriously sick so the side effect can be overlooked because of the outcome is good.

    4 Will you allow your children to be vaccinated?
    probably I will with certain vaccines that have been proven in long term use to be absolutely beneficial.

    ReplyDelete
  8. 4. I would allow my children to be vaccinated. Not only do they have weaker immune systems, but they are often in high interaction circumstances. Especially at school, children are exposed to each others' sicknesses. Some of these sicknesses are a result of a lack of cleanliness that children would be more prone to carry out. In addition, these diseases could be spread to siblings and then spread to other schools. Children are even more prone to sickness than adults. Parents should vaccinate their kids. This will assist in the prevention of disease.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Tracy Santoyo (Harriger)September 8, 2011 at 5:10 PM

    As Christian clearly outlined, the risks associated with vaccination range from mild (slight soreness) to severe (a life threatening allergic reaction). But in general, an individual is more likely to experience mild side effects (if any) such as soreness and redness in the area where the shot was administered, rather than be severely harmed to the point of near death.
    For many vaccines more severe, but not deathly, side effects include headaches, seizures, vomiting, and muscle and joint pain. The MMR vaccine, specifically, has been associated with deafness, coma, and even brain damage. Some even claim that the vaccine, when given to small children, has the ability to induce autism.
    I personally believe that the slight risk associated with vaccines is well-worth taking, considering the severity of the diseases that they are intended to prevent. Considering how much medical treatment costs, and how much physical damage can be done to one’s body once one of these diseases has been acquired, it is much more sensible to be vaccinated.
    If I have children they will be vaccinated, unless future evidence determines that vaccination causes debilitating harm over time. As the evidence stands right now, the likelihood of having a severe reaction to any vaccine is not great enough to deter me from this form of immunization.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Documented mild-moderate side-effects of vaccines:
    On the appendage where shot was given––tenderness, redness, itching, lumps, bruise, restricted muscle movement, joint pain, warmth, muscle pain, swelling; headaches; fatigue; fever; fussiness; loss of appetite; vomiting; nausea; seizure; non-stop crying (for DTaP vaccine); high fever; fainting; sore throat; red/itchy eyes; wheezing/cough; abdominal pain; chills; runny nose/nasal congestion

    Documented severe side-effects of vaccines
    anaphylactic shock; seizures; induce coma; permanent brain damage; Guillain-Barré Syndrome (Meningococcal and Influenza vaccine); death

    It is true that vaccine shots have many negative side-effects, but the same thing can also be said of the majority of other drugs. Just check out any of the drugs in commercials, often times the listing out of negative side-effects takes off more than half of the commercial itself. Yet people still use take them; the reason behind this is because, albeit the cons of taking them, the pros far outweigh it. The field of medicine has always been and still is like this. There is no single remedy for medical conditions that does not have a negative side to it. Be it through drugs, therapy, surgery, etc. So, to answer question number 3, I think that despite having its downside vaccination is still a very good/safe option for preventing disease. And so with this in mind, my answer to question number 4 is also yes, I will allow my children to be vaccinated. Heck, Lord willing, If I become a doctor, I'll vaccinate them myself.

    ReplyDelete
  11. One more thing. Another factor to weigh in with regards to the safety of vaccines is the general location of where the vaccinee (person who received the vaccine) lives. There are some countries that present a higher chance of acquiring a vaccine-preventable disease than others. In these cases, the plus factor of getting vaccinated is increased. If the vaccinee lives in an area where public health and safety is higher, the pros of getting vaccinated may not be as much; but even then, vaccination is still a good option.

    ReplyDelete
  12. There is no perfectly safe vaccine. Though the percentage is low, there is a possibility that any vaccine can cause a true reaction. In very specific cases, the vaccine has the ability to “leap” to another. Vaccines also relate to allergic reactions and autoimmune responses. A few of the side effects include headaches, fever, pain, inflammation, rash, deafness, seizures, and brain damage. Despite these side effects I have an overall optimistic view of vaccines. Though people need to be aware of the potential risks of vaccines, and therefore be cautious, there is no reason to completely reject vaccines. Clearly, the positive greatly outweigh the negatives. The most common side effects are mild and those that are more severe are much more rare. Though attempts are made to associate very severe side effects, such as autism, to vaccines, there is still not nearly a sufficient amount of evidence to seriously consider the claim. In light of all this, I will vaccinate my children.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Another point to be made about child vaccination is that though vaccines can be harmful to the immune system, especially in children, the benefits still outweigh the negatives. Protection from infections for my child in his/her early development is very important to me, and so is the development of his/her immune system. Therefore, it seems best to follow the recommended course of vaccines with the only exception of extending out the scheduled vaccines a little in order to allow the child’s immune system sufficient time to recover and develop between each vaccine.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Tracy Santoyo (Harriger)September 10, 2011 at 11:27 PM

    I really appreciate Christian's comment regarding the purpose of vaccination in preventing the spread of disease in populations vs. preventing personal illness. The success of vaccines has been proven overwhelmingly in this arena as several diseases have been declared eradicated, eliminated or on their way to eradication because of the administering of vaccines throughout the world (i.e. Smallpox, Polio, Measles, etc.).
    Those individuals who advocate not vaccinating children, in particular (as Christian pointed out, they are a major source of the spread of disease to other children and adults), have not considered the fact that they are, unintentionally, advocating the further spread and strengthening of disease. By not having children vaccinated, their immune systems are both weakened and unprepared to fight off such diseases.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I probably would not allow my kids to be vaccinated until they had somewhat of a stronger immune system. Do to the fact that the vaccines are not that helpful to the immune system at the time of the vaccination they are very helpful later when the patient comes into contact with that certain bacteria or disease. Plus as Andrew said that there is actually y no perfectly harmless vaccines out there yet so it would be beneficial to study the side effects first before allowing your kids to be vaccinated.

    ReplyDelete