Saturday, August 27, 2011

redundancy in the immune system, design or chance?


One of the things we will note about the mammalian immune system in this course is how it displays redundancy. What I mean by this is that the immune system possesses many different mechanisms to remove or neutralize pathogens. For instance, the complement system is a blood born system that is like a mini-immune system all by itself. It has components which can bind and neutralize or kill bacteria. But so can many other parts of the immune system like leukocytes and antibodies and other enzymatic factors.
Why is the immune system so redundant? Is this inefficient design? If so is the immune system better explained by an evolutionary origin? Or is redundancy an example of something you would find in a designed system? Discuss your thoughts with your classmates and others who might join the blog.

19 comments:

  1. Although the immune system may seem redundant, maybe these redundancies allow the body to eliminate the Pathogens more efficiently. Maybe the blood born mini-immune system has a special purpose or is more effective at dealing with blood born pathogens than the other parts of the immune system. Maybe the blood born invaders need to be removed quickly and a mini-immune system would be able to provide this speed. Our cardiovascular system provides an excellent system for transporting our leukocytes to the site of infection. Maybe we have a blood born immune system because of this transportation track.

    Instead of redundant, maybe the immune system should be considered as thorough. Our immune system's large arsenal helps us prevent the variety of sicknesses our bodies are prone to. For example, Killer-T cells specialize in phagocytosis of infected cells, whereas B-cells specialize in producing antibodies. With all of it's complexity, our immune system is better explained by a designed system. Although the redundancies may suggest evolution, the redundancies may provide more efficiency or necessary additional protection. Our immune system is truly amazing, like the one who designed it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Erik, thanks for starting the discussion. The cardio system is a distribution system, yet the fluid dynamics and the force that result work against localization of white blood cells...yet there is a mechanism for this...interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Okay, so the cardio system prevents white blood cells from localizing because of the current. How are they transported throughout our body to fight infection? What about the mechanism for blood clotting that enables blood cells to attach to the edge of blood vessels to form clots?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with Eric that the redundancies of the immune system are efficient, yet the cellular and humoral responses carried out are not simple. They are very intricate and complex. Consider the bonding of antigens to antibodies. While the general process of an antigen bonding to a cell demonstrates immunological redundancy and efficiency, the complexity of the system is apparent in that the receptor for each antigen is specific. A key fits the lock it is made for; a particular antigen fits its specific receptor and no other. In light of this, when we think about the many antigens and their respective receptors, we realize what we see and know is probably only a small fraction of the greater complexity we are not aware of. In addition, all this complexity is tied together by a common framework or underlying general immunological response process, which supports a common design and Designer. Evolution does not seem as plausible when redundancy is coupled with complexity.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Good points both Emma and Erik...I think that this idea of binding and binding sites also applies to enzymes and substrates, and it could be argued that the binding specificity it refined over time.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Tracy Santoyo (Harriger)August 29, 2011 at 8:35 PM

    The ability of the mammalian immune system to neutralize pathogens in many different ways is not a sign of redundancy, but rather efficient design. Consider the body to be like the machinery in any given factory today. If one part of the machinery breaks in a factory, there are usually many different protective measures that have been instigated to stop the system and prevent anything (or anyone) from being harmed or further damaged. If the first set of protective measures does not work, the second sets are there as a “fall back” to make sure the system is halted.
    So it can be seen with the human body – the skin being the primary protective barrier, with more specific forms of protection being seen throughout the human body. When this protective measure fails, another protective measure, perhaps leukocytes or the complement system will be activated to halt pathogens.
    This is certainly evidence of a Designer. From an evolutionary standpoint, it would be far more efficient simply to activate one response that would be entirely destructive to any pathogen. Instead, a complex system that is both broad and specific can be seen in the mammalian immune response. To quote Erik, it is “thorough,” not redundant.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with the comments laid out so far––redundancy doesn't necessarily mean inefficiency, in fact, quite the contrary. Tracy compared the redundancy of the immune system to that of fail-safe systems found in factories, where preventive measures are incorporated so that when one fails, or is unable to do it's job efficiently, another one is activated to compensate and save the whole system from total failure. We see another example of this "redundancy" in airports where a passenger passes through numerous x-rays and document checks. Their redundancy provides a more thorough security for the airport as a whole.

    From an evolutionary standpoint, though, the redundancy found in the immune system may be a good thing. These redundancies––slightly different processes that generally serve the same function––may be used as evidence for an evolutionary origin. But as what Tracy and the others have mentioned earlier, the intricacy and efficiency found in the immune system make it undeniably a result of Intelligent Design.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think that maybe there are so many different antigens and antibodies because each one would pick up a specific bacteria by using the specific receptor as emma said that it's only is for a specific antigen then couldn't it be possible that each antigen is specific for each specific bacteria or disease it takes out. So it like multiple levels of security to get into the body, and without this we would be very susceptible to other common diseases.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The complexity of the immune system is what strikes me. Why are there so many barriers to protect our bodies? There is an obvious value to life that can be seen in the study of immunology. It is difficult to think that all these barriers could evolve to what they are today, much less one of them evolve over millions of years. Just looking at the eyeball and its areas of defense against disease is amazing. And that's only the surface. Antibodies and T cells take protection of an organism to a minute molecular level. While God can create and destroy the immune system in less time than it takes to blink an eye, evolution requires millions of years, and even that amount of time is not enough for the complexity humans are able to observe in their frames that will become dust.

    ReplyDelete
  11. "Why is the immune system so redundant?"

    The function of the immune system is the protection of the organism. The best way to construct an answer to this is to assess how analogous defenses are designed and structured.

    Take a military compound, for example. If you were to enter any military base, there would be structured levels of security to ensure that only the appropriate persons would be in the appropriate places at the appropriate times. Even personnel of the base are appropriated and restricted to/from certain areas of the base due to their rank and function.

    All personnel have a badge/keycard unique to each person, which confers them with privileges to certain areas and resources. They may be required to present it to a scanner or guard to be permitted access to the aforementioned areas. While there is specificity with each guard assessing each individual, there are also fortifications and systems that are exceedingly redundant to enhance security. A prime example of this would be gates and doorways.

    Whether a military base or citidel, anything that needs protection always has multiple levels of fortifications to contain invaders. There is one gate for the first level, then another for the second, and another for the third, and so on. Imagine the scene from Return of the King, where the orcs have breeched the main gate. While they have penetrated the city, they are afforded limited access at a time due to the redundancy of gates being positioned systematically along the path to the center.

    Some compounds are sealed and only accessible by key-card or fingerprint/iris scan, and while some may be able to get through the first line of defense, the successive ones will continue to decrease the probability of successful invasion by an intruder.

    Redundancy is, by design, the most effective means of general defense there is, because it places more barriers in line of the invader, with each event decreasing the probability of invasion success.

    However, sometimes more specific means are required. Computers and systems can be deactivated, fooled, or overwhelmed. In this case you need a more active method of removing the invader, which is where individual guard units come into play. Both the passive (or innate) and the active (and adaptive) defenses work to isolate and nullify threats to the system. Multiple layers of defense are a necessity to ensure protection. If only one line of defense were present, and then breached, it would result in the destruction of the system. No defense, regardless of its individual fortitude, will ever be 100% effective. Therefore it is imperative that multiple lines of defense are designed and implemented.

    Evolutionarily, this raises some dilemmas, because even if the immune system evolved, how were multi-cellular organisms surviving before it evolved? Once some primitive immune system had evolved, how would it be effective with limited lines of defense?

    If it was survival of the fittest alone, then you would expect that all living organisms today would still be single-celled colonies, because multicellular organisms would continually succumb to the various creatures that we define as pathogens today.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think, another point as to why redundancy in the immune system is necessary is because it is more efficient that way. What I mean by this is that if it were not redundant, to ensure security of the organism, the immune system would have to be sent out in full force all the time for every and any foreign invader. Also, without redundancy, the immune system could be overwhelmed if multiple antigens were to invade at once. Redundancy, however, allows the immune system to address multiple antigens locally.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great points all. Many of you have given interesting examples of how redundancy could be part of design. Of course it could be argued that this is "bad design" or suboptimal design in the first place, because why could not a benevolent creator make creature and a world where no defense is needed.

    On the other hand, we could also think of the concept of "overdesign", i.e., the immune system looks overdesigned in many ways to me. It seems that if evolution could create the immune system it would possibly create one that is efficient but not overdesigned.....overdesign does not seem to fit the evolutionary paradigm. Please feel free to comment on bad design and overdesign as we wrap up this first blog!! Remember you need to entries for full credit

    ReplyDelete
  14. It seems to me that “redundancy” in our immune system is a result of the fall, not a necessarily negative result, yet a result. The need for multiple layers in our immune systems seems to reveal the inefficiency of our bodies. If our immune system was perfectly efficient, then we would need only one layer of defense that would not be breached. However, because we have multiple layers that are at times breached, there seems to be more evidence pointing to the inefficiency of our bodies, which is very consistent with post-fall theology. It seems that the Lord, in his grace, gave us multiple mechanism for our protection. So, it would be hard for me to say that our immune system is more efficient because of its multiple mechanism. Rather, I would say that our immune system is more effective because of the multiple layers considering our fallen state. What’s more efficient, one thing accomplishing one task or multiple things accomplishing that same task? Another good question we could ask is, “What will our immune system look like in our glorified state where we will be perfectly efficient?” … Entertaining the idea that will have an immune system.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I really appreciate Emma’s comment on the question over evolutionary origin. It would be hard to support evolutionary origin knowing the complexity of the immune system. To achieve the complexity of immune system over time is much more improbable than if it were to all come together at once.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Tracy Santoyo (Harriger)September 3, 2011 at 7:59 PM

    I think Andrew has a very good point when he points out that the multiple layers of the immune system point to the inefficiency of our bodies. The fact that sin has such a detrimental effect on our physical state is very clear in the fact that such a complex immune system is necessary to protect us. Had we perfect bodies, like those of Adam and Eve prior to the Fall, our immune systems would appear to be greatly over designed.
    That being said, it begs the question why God created such a complex immune system prior to the Fall. Could this be bad design? Perhaps. But why would God, who created a perfect work, create seemingly less than perfect bodies? I would argue that God, in his perfect foreknowledge created our bodies with the ability to defend ourselves from pathogens, knowing that sin would enter into the world and cause our bodies to deteriorate. Prior to that moment though, the immune system could have been used for many things, including assistance in maintaining a balance between ourselves and outside physical environment.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Protection in the immune system can be spit in the two groups that the book describes as recognition and response the recognition part is the one that can recognize by components and or patterns. They do this by pathogens. These pathogens distinguish enemy pathogens from good pathogens as Dr. Francis said in class "to tell the difference from self and not self". The pathogens when they sense an enemy they will they activates the effector response. My question is how/or what does this is there a certain antibody that the pathogen releases that notifies the effector response? Or something else?... The innate system is another question I have is it says that the innate immunity has cellular mechanisms that are pre-deployed before an infection for a rapid attack, what causes this to be pre-deployed? Does the infection release's something that alarms the innate system? Or is it always deployed. Cause as we know that it is the first security check point per say so there is no other system that can alert it. Adaptive immunity seems to be the second level of security in the immune system. This one however seems to only become active when it sense and invading pathogen or infection but it take it out before pathogenesis occurs. Again how it does it know there is an invading pathogen? I think the most amazing part of the adaptive system is the memory cells, which I think of them like cell ninjas that strike super fast and eliminate all targets. Mediated immunity has to have both humoral and cellular responses acting to be able to innate mission shutdown of foreign pathogen and other harmful infections. So redundancy in the immune system is kind of hard to prove due to the fact that all of the immune systems guards seem to take out certain types of pathogen of infections.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Looking from a creation design model, I assume that the initial purpose of the immune system was to regulate microbes and to maintain them in their appropriated places throughout the body. I a perfect world everything would be kept where it is supposed to be. We observe today that there are a variety of symbiotic bacteria and fungi that occur naturally in and on our bodies. These are either mutualistic or commensal when in their appropriate locations. They can, however, become pathogenic when in the wrong place (eg. bacteria of the mouth getting in the bloodstream, causing infective endocarditis), or opportunistic when the immune system ceases to regulate properly (eg. AIDS leading to candidiasis).

    In a perfect world, the immune system (which was most likely more of a regulatory system) would regulate perfectly. To do this, it may have utilized various homologous systems to regulate the symbiotes of the body. While homologous, these systems may have had significant levels of specificity to regulating specific organisms.

    It is appropriate to assume that in a fallen world this system has degraded in some form. It is possible that we see redundancy in the immune system because many of the homologous mechanisms have lost some of their specificity with regard to function.

    It is quite possible we are investigating the ruins of a once extremely complex and specific system. While it is still quite specific by observation, it can be likened to looking on the ruins of Ancient Rome. Many Roman ruins look very similar because they've degraded over time, yet we have written accounts by which to base our interpretations of what they previously were. How interesting it would be if we have written accounts of how the immune system functioned thousands of years ago. Perhaps it could have been the critical element responsible for the longevity of man in the pre-flood account. It is important to remember the issue of semantics when referring to the 'immune' system. We call it so because of what we currently observe it to do. It may have very well had (and still have) far more function than we ever will discover or give credit.

    ReplyDelete