In the old TV series "Lost in Space" Will Robinson was warned by his robot when danger approached. In theoretical immunology a relatively new theory called the danger hypothesis is a challenge to the self vs non-self theory. In the danger hypothesis, broken down cell components alert the immune system. This may be more of a "priority" signal than signals from the PRR part of the innate immune system. Learn more about this hypothesis and answer the following questions.
1 What is the data that supports this theory?
2 Do you think this is a challenge to the self vs non-self theory?
3 Is it possible that PRRs are involved in the danger mechanism of immune activation?

In 1994,a guy named Polly Matzinger
ReplyDeleteintroduced this hypothesis which suggested that the immune system is mainly adapted to recognize and respond to signals generated in a dangerous situation that involves cell damage which became known as the "danger hypothesis," is based on the idea that the crucial signals for the initiation of immune responses are endogenous, not exogenous.
According to this hypothesis, the power is with the tissues the activation state of Antigen-presenting cells would depend on the health of cells in their surrounding area.
What is the evidence in support of this idea It has been that the recognition of microbial molecular patterns by Toll-like receptors initiates immune responses that are critical for
the control of infections. there is also evidence that TLR mediated microbial recongnition depending on whether the stimuli originates from pathogenic or non-pathogenic organisms. non-pathogenic common bacteria induce TLR mediated signaling in the gut, but under standard conditions this does not trigger an inflammatory response by that which caused by pathogenic bacteria. Thus, in many instances the initiation of immune responses seems to require tissue damage, which is a speciality of pathogenic microorganisms. In addition to having mechanisms for invading and crossing cell barriers, pathogenic microbes produce a large number of membrane-damaging molecules,
this does not seem to challenge the self to non-self theory it almost comes along side it.
PRRs they seem to be used to warn the immune response system when there is cell damage as the above. i think that the PRRs are being used to recongnize the cell damage and because of that it develops a patterns memory that will warn via the IMS.
"Membrane Repair and Immunological Danger." Web. 03 Oct. 2011. .
Web. 03 Oct. 2011. .
The Danger Hypothesis.docx - 4shared.com - Online File Sharing and Storage - Download." 4shared.com - Free File Sharing and Storage. Web. 03 Oct. 2011.
The danger hypothesis, first developed by Polly Matzinger, was a theory that concluded that the immune system does not respond to the presence of non-self antigens in the body, but that the immune system will recognize and destroy anything in the body that has the potential to harm or destroy it, including molecules and chemicals often recognized as “self.” This response is activated when Antigen-presenting cells activate T-cells via a receptor called a “danger signal.” This theory is supported by the fact that the immune system responds even at times when infection from a pathogen is not present, such as when the body experiences trauma, causing its own cells to be destroyed. It is also safe to say that the danger hypothesis is much more logical when considering the body’s immune response to tumors or the induction of auto-immune diseases (neither involve infection by a pathogen); self vs. non-self and pattern-recognition receptor theories cannot explain how an immune response is induced when foreign material is not involved.
ReplyDeleteWhen Matzinger proposed this theory, it seems that her intent was to disprove self vs. non-self theories. The danger hypothesis concludes that that such a recognition pattern cannot be responsible for activating an immune response due to the fact that immune responses are induced without the presence of foreign antigens. But the fact that the body does respond to the presence of foreign materials in the body based on the fact that they are obviously not human (the recognition of a conserved molecular pattern on the pathogen), it would seem that the danger hypothesis and self vs. non-self theories probably are both involved in the human immune response, rather than simply one or the other.
The danger theory stemmed out of the inability to use the self-non-self model to explain the details of how immune responses are initiated. The self-non-self model was the main theory throughout the 1950’s. However, when antigen presenting cells were discovered in the 1980’s, the self-non-self model was reconsidered. Charles Janeway proposed the idea that the body actually depends on the innate immune system for immune responses. In 1994, Polly Matzinger further proposed that antigen-presenting cells respond to danger signals. Cells undergoing injury or death would send out signals telling the immune system to respond. She argued that immune response was based on neither on recognition of self, nor on recognition of pathogens, but it is actually based on a response to cellular damage. Since this theory does not depend on the presence of pathogens as the self-non-self theory does, it would help explain why there are immune responses where there are no antigens present, such as in tumors or autoimmune diseases. So far this seems to be the only solid support the theory can rely upon.
ReplyDeleteMatzinger seems to have intended to disprove the self-non-self model through her theory. And although she does have support for her theory, there is still too much support in favor of the self-non-self model to completely rule it out. The body does responses very effectively in the presence of non-self in a way that seems to be independent of cellular damage, which suggests that the immune system is able to differentiate between self and non-self. Therefore, it is possible that PRRs are involved in the danger mechanism of immune activation.
ReplyDeleteMatzinger suggests that the "patterns" that the immune system recognizes on bacteria are not as different from the alarm signals released by damaged cells as one might have thought. They suggested that, because life evolved in water, the hydrophobic portions (Hyppos) of molecules are normally hidden in the internal parts of molecules or other structures (like membranes) and that the sudden exposure of a Hyppo is a sure sign that some injury or damage has occurred. They suggested that these are the most ancient alarm signals, that they are recognized by evolutionarily ancient systems of repair and remodeling, and that the modern immune system piggy-backed on this ancient system. Thus bacteria and other organisms may have very similar alarm systems. They describe these ancient signals as Danger-associated molecular patterns, or DAMPs.
ReplyDeleteMatzinger argues that the idea of DAMPs may explain why Toll-like receptors seem to respond both to external and endogenous signals. This is supported by some evidence but nowhere near enough to disprove the self vs non-self theory. PRRs probably are involved in the danger mechanism of the immune systems activation because the body typically can distinguish self from non-self.
ReplyDelete1) The data to support the theory.
ReplyDeleteThe data support this theory in many the same ways as the self-nonself (SNS) theory. The differences lie in perspective and the model itself. The primary premise of the danger theory is that the immune system does not spontaneously respond to immunogens, but rather responds only in the presence of 'danger signals:' regulating chemicals given off by cell destruction. Another deviation from the SNS theory is that the immune system doesn't inherently distinguish self from non-self, but that it becomes tolerant to the presence of antigens in the healthy environment. In summary, when things aren't as they should be, cells respond by releasing agents that activate antigen presenting cells, thus initiating the immune response.
As a personal aside, I believe that this is an elegantly proposed theory, and that it is consistent with the lack of SNS distinction in the complement system.
There are many circumstances which may be interpreted in support of the theory. Presented are a few of the more prominent examples:
If fetuses are not rejected because they are healthy and do not send alarm signals, why does an Rh negative mother respond to her Rh positive fetus?
It was previously proposed that the fetus caused some type of immune suppression in the mother. This is not a very good explanation for why the mother doesn't initiate an immune response against a fetus, let alone the first Rh positive fetus. In the first Rh pregnancy the baby is carried to term without an immune response. It is hypothesized that the immune system responds to the Rh antigens during labor, in which there is considerable trauma to the mother. This trauma is thought to activate the antigen presenting cells, which affect an immune response against future Rh+ fetuses. It also begs the question why a mother doesn't respond to the baby as she would a foreign organ transplant. The hypothesis is that the baby is present under healthy conditions, and thus the immune system is tolerant to its presence as it would be to the rest of the host.
Another example is that of commensal bacteria. Why does our immune system not mount a full-force response against our natural flora? There are antigens present on them, and they are obviously non-self. Why then does the immune system not react against flora in our mouths, GI tract, and sexual tracts? I think it is a sound assessment that there is more than self-nonself distinction regulating our immune responses.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI wish to respond to 2 and 3 together as they are intrinsically linked questions.
ReplyDeleteThe danger model doesn't necessarily challenge the SNS theory, at least in the sense of outright opposing it. It is more of an augment of the SNS theory. Dr. Matzinger elucidates the differences:
"Tolerance in self-reactive cells looks like a self-non-self definition; consequently the difference between Danger and SNS has sometimes been dismissed as semantics. But semantics has to do with meaning, and the models do not give the same meanings to the words "self" and "foreign". In a SNS model, the word "foreign" means "that to which the immune system should respond" and "self" means "that to which the immune system should be tolerant". The Danger model uses the words "self" and "foreign" to distinguish things encoded by our own genes from those encoded by other organisms. We can therefore speak about "self-tolerance" and understand each other. But these meanings have no impact on the decision to respond, which is governed by the presence or absence of alarm signals. Because most self is harmless (and persists) we will be constantly inducing tolerance to it. But tolerance will also be induced to antigens expressed by commensal organisms, and by parasites that do no cellular damage, so that the set of things to which the immune system becomes tolerant is not the same as "self", but encompasses any persistent antigen that is not associated with danger."
Herein lies the major distinction: the determination of response. This model doesn't necessarily refute the SNS model, but focuses on the factors regulating the response to antigens. The greatest premise is that the antigens themselves are not the primary simulators of immunogenic response.
I believe that PRRs are indeed involved in the danger model, as it doesn't inherently exclude these from the immune response mechanism. The danger model proposes that the PRRs are regulated by danger signals from damaged or otherwise traumatized cells. These signals activate the Antigen Presenting Cells (APCs), which then activate T cells. The signals could also activate, upregulate, or stimulate synthesis of PRRs to function in pathogen recognition and mount the appropriate responses.
If assessed from an intelligent design model, I think that the danger model fits more effectively due to the dynamic nature of immunity that it hypothesizes. I have previously put forth the idea that the immune system may not have always functioned to combat disease, but rather to regulate the appropriations of commensal species, and physiology and host maintenance. We see this particularly with macrophages, as they scavenge destroyed cells (by apoptosis or trauma) and debris from our system. This model touches on the dynamic nature of this mysterious system, and by nature hints at possible alternative functions of the immune system that have not been previously investigated.
With regards to Dr. Francis’ 3rd question:
ReplyDeleteI believe Christian stated it best. Pattern-recognition receptors are likely involved in the Danger Model as the presence of particular molecular configurations on the surface of pathogens activate a danger signal within the immune system, thus inducing activity of APCs and T cells. But it cannot be disregarded that there is a possibility that PRRs work outside of danger signals. Knowing that antibodies are able to recognize antigens based the structure and chemical make-up of that antigen, there is the possibility of PRRs being a completely separate working portion of the immune system.
The Danger Model was proposed by Matzinger to explain why T cells respond to tissue transplants, tumors, and autoimmune diseases. In this model, a dying cell releases DAMPs (damage-associated molecular patterns)that work as adjuvants, activating APCs (antigen-presenting cells) and stimulating the immune response. Data that supports this theory includes experiments involving a mixture of antigen and dead cells that stimulated immune responses when injected into animals. In addition, autoimmune diabetes occurs in mice upon death of pancreatic beta-islet cells. Another experiment also showed that dead cancer cells did in fact stimulate T cell responses.
ReplyDeleteSo why does some cell death stimulate immune response and others do not? One big reason could be that people more prone to autoimmune diseases will be more greatly affected by the death of a cell. Consequently, the adjuvant activity could cause more of an immune response in such people.
I do not believe the danger hypothesis challenges the self vs nonself theory. The danger hypothesis posits that DAMPs only act as adjuvants. This means they are only strengthening the immune response. Therefore, though DAMPs are foreign (the cell membrane protects them until its death), they are not always effective on their own. It appears, as mentioned above, a person should probably be predisposed to autoimmunity to stimulate greater immune activity.
Experimental evidence does not rule out PRRs (pattern recognition receptors) being involved in the danger hypothesis. Rather,DAMPs appear to work right along with the adaptive immune system, serving to stimulate interactions between PRRs and APCs (antigen to antibody interactions). If cell death does act like an adjuvant, then PRRs are still a large part of the immune response.
Some DAMPs have been purified and identified with Toll-like receptors, including TLR2 AND TLR4. It is interesting to note that death-induced neutrophilic inflammation decreased significantly in mice lacking MyD88, a key protein in the TLR signalling pathway. Therefore, TLRs may play a role in cell death and DAMP release.
ReplyDeleteThe danger model was proposed by Polly Matzinger as an alternative to the self-non-self (SNS) theory. The SNS theory had been the prevailing theory since the 1950s but during the 1980s questions regarding its validity arose because it was unable to explain certain documented occurrences. Examples of these occurrences include: auto-immune diseases; our non-reaction to our own changing body (during pregnancy) or to the food we eat (under the category of non-self). So, to this, the danger theory offers an alternative mechanism for immune activation.
ReplyDeleteThe danger theory proposes that instead of the immune system being activated by non-self molecules in the body, it becomes activated when our own cells are being damaged. In other words, the immune system responds to "danger signals" mainly caused/presented by cells undergoing damage/injury, stress and death.
When Polly Matzinger first proposed this theory, she intended it to be an alternative/replacement of the SNS theory. There is strong evidence to support the validity of this theory, but even so, because there is still strong, supporting evidence to the SNS theory we cannot rule it out. So, to answer question 2--no, I do not believe it presents a danger to the SNS theory. I agree with Tracy, I think with further development and study, both theories will prove to be true in some sense instead of just having either one.
ReplyDeleteMatzinger believes that damaged cells present patterns similar to what bacteria present. These patterns called DAMPS (Danger-associated molecular patterns) have similar functions to PAMPs in that they "reveal" patterns that can be perceived by receptors (DARRs? Damage-associated Recognizing Receptors?) and thus activate the immune system. So, to answer question 3, I think PRR-like proteins are involved in the danger theory model.
I think that when Polly fist introduced the theory she did not intend it to take the place of the main theory at that time. the immune detection is specific in many regards considering the dander hypothesis which is a antigen-presenting cells that respond to "danger signals"....
ReplyDeleteand i put in my first blog that Polly was a guy so i am correcting that right now..